Choose a vehicle
Find your Tesla and save your favorites.
Used Tesla Model Y in NY listings
80 vehicles to explore starting at $20,170 (median $32,098 · 24 price finds below peer benchmark). Dealer confirmation is required before reservation.
Featured vehicles & market benchmark snapshot
- 2023 Model Y Performance — $20,170, 151,219 mi, New Hyde Park; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $21,049, 139,095 mi, Liverpool; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $22,470 (Save $527 vs. $22,997 peer benchmark), 120,000 mi, East Meadow; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $23,170, 59,297 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2023 Model Y Long Range — $23,890, 83,415 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2020 Model Y Long Range — $24,269, 99,968 mi, Farmington; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $24,269, 113,445 mi, Farmington; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2020 Model Y Long Range — $24,385, 95,731 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $24,567, 102,695 mi, Binghamton; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Long Range — $25,063, 110,766 mi, Liverpool; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Long Range AWD — $25,136, 97,781 mi, Fishkill; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2023 Model Y Performance — $25,470 (Save $1,339 vs. $26,809 peer benchmark), 132,014 mi, Long Island city ; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2020 Model Y Long Range — $25,670, 56,400 mi, New Hyde Park; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $25,675, 93,848 mi, Rome; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2023 Model Y Long Range — $25,920 (Save $1,500 vs. $27,420 peer benchmark), 103,502 mi, Brooklyn; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Performance — $25,950, 97,243 mi, Saratoga Springs; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2023 Model Y Base — $26,000 (Save $1,500 vs. $27,500 peer benchmark), 119,015 mi, New York; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Performance — $26,990, 96,446 mi, Bay Shore; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Long Range — $27,100 (Save $1,499 vs. $28,599 peer benchmark), 78,689 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $27,190 (Save $1,401 vs. $28,591 peer benchmark), 65,685 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $27,190 (Save $800 vs. $27,990 peer benchmark), 72,002 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Performance — $27,400 (Save $1,500 vs. $28,900 peer benchmark), 85,865 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2021 Model Y Long Range — $27,470 (Save $732 vs. $28,202 peer benchmark), 64,408 mi, Great Neck; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
- 2022 Model Y Long Range — $27,490 (Save $1,500 vs. $28,990 peer benchmark), 73,549 mi, Commack; estimated vehicle price, tax, title and delivery quoted separately.
ALL TESLA. ALL ONLINE.
Find your next Tesla.
Shop used Teslas nationwide in one place. Compare market price savings, get a complete out-the-door quote from the selling dealer, and reserve online for $250, refundable.
1 Pick your Tesla & ZIP2 Get exact dealer quote ($0 today)3 Reserve for $250 (refundable)
One purchase experience.
Shop here. Review your quote here. Independent dealers own and fulfill each vehicle.
Estimated vehicle prices. Tax, title, and delivery are quoted separately.
No vehicles match these filters. Try a wider search.
A PURCHASE YOU CAN FOLLOW
Every step has a clear checkpoint.
Online reservations are being connected. Browsing and saved favorites are available.
Review your complete price
Review vehicle evidence, the licensed seller, delivery, taxes, and purchase terms.
Reserve your Tesla
After seller confirmation, reserve for $250 under the refund terms shown at checkout. Your deposit counts toward the purchase.
Track your purchase
Follow dealer confirmation, payment, transport, and delivery.